Father Michael & Grace Group Walkthrough Part 5

After you leave the church, head straight to the school and go inside. You'll ecounter Father Michael hiding inside a protective circle. It doesn't really matter what path you take through the dialogue. Madeline will intervene and you'll end up going outside to talk to her.

Exhaust your dialogue options with Madeline. Don't forget to ask her about the Grace Group from your notes. Then head back inside to talk to Father Michael again. From your notes ask him about the Grace Group. Then close the notes and follow all dialogue options relating to the Grace Group.